Dear Dr. Jann. I have been a bonusdad, as you call us, for a little more than a year now. I have a great relationship with my “bonussons,” but one thing really bothers me. They are usually pretty affectionate—except when we drop them off at their dad’s house. They give their mom a hug good bye, but then we all stand around awkwardly. On the rare occasion when their mother takes them from our house to their dad’s house I get good-bye hugs. I think they feel in the middle and I don’t know what to do to help them.

Dr. Jann says:  There’s good news and bad news when kids act like this—the good news is that they like you. The bad news is their positive feelings for you actually tests their allegiance to their dad. They don’t want their dad to feel as if they have chosen you over him, so they hide their feelings for you when their dad is around. It’s a lot of pressure on them—and you are wise to look for ways to help.
Divorced parents often secretly worry that the bonusparent will replace them in their children’s eyes, and in response, inadvertently act in ways that place their kids right in the middle. If the dad is not openly making comments, his actions may have given his sons the impression that you are the enemy. You can help by raising them to understand that they can love their dad and still have a good relationship with you—and let Dad know he need not fear. You will continue to promote his positive relationship with them.
Old school divorce and remarriage dictated that parents and bonusparents rarely talked, but it’s obvious that you both live with the boys at different times and are performing similar tasks. This puts you in direct competition with each other and if you don’t adopt a new attitude about divorce and remarriage, the kids will continue to be stuck right in the middle. The only way not to step on each other’s toes is to talk to each other and coordinate efforts. We’re not saying go play golf together, but don’t be afraid to talk to each other and establish ground rules about your responsibilities to the kids.
Another good way to take the pressure off the kids is by acknowledging how lucky they are to have such a great dad and how you think he is lucky to have them. Don’t prevent phone calls when they are with you and make sure they feel comfortable talking about their dad in front of you. Do your best not to invade their territory—if dad and the boys are planning a camping trip on their weekend together, don’t plan one the weekend before to overshadow their big day or plan another special outing with friends of the family when the boys are scheduled to go with their dad. Be careful what you say about him when the kids are present.
Sounds like it’s all up to you? Not really. You just asked first.

Sign up for our newsletter today and get exclusive coParenting content.


About Jann Blackstone

Jann BlackstoneDr. Jann Blackstone specializes in divorce, child custody, co-parenting, and stepfamily mediation and is often called the “Relationship Expert for Today’s Relationships” because of her “real life, down-to-earth” approach to relationship problem solving. She is the author of six books on divorce and parenting, the most popular, the Ex-etiquette series featuring Ex-etiquette for Parents: Good Behavior After Divorce or Separation. She is also the author of the Ex-etiquette syndicated column and a frequent guest or consultant on television and radio talk shows, including Good Morning America (ABC), The Today Show (NBC), Keeping Kids Healthy (PBS), the Early Show (CBS), and The Oprah Winfrey Show. She has been the featured expert in many magazines, including, Child, Parents, Parenting, Newsweek, Family Circle, More, Good Housekeeping, Redbook, BRIDES, Woman’s Day, and Working Mother Magazine.

In 1999, Dr. Jann founded and became the first Director of Bonus Families®, a 501 (c) (3) non-profit organization working to change the way society views stepfamilies by supplying up-to-date co-parenting information via its Web site, counseling, mediation, and a worldwide support group network. They prefer to use the word “bonus” to the word step. Step implies negative things; however, a “bonus” is a reward for a job well done. “Bonus…a step in the right direction.”

Tags: ,